Friday, April 2, 2010
Amazon's strategic blunder - what were they (not) thinking?
It's been fascinating following the debate raging in the US about ebook pricing and business models, particularly the argy bargy over the so-called agency model, and the tug of war between Amazon and Apple for publisher allegiance.
In my humble view things are going from bad to worse.
I cannot understand the thinking behind Amazon's embrace of the agency model of ebook supply. Oh sure, I can understand how it got there, albeit reluctantly. It capitulated to Macmillan's threat to not do business with it unless it adopted the business model advanced by Apple that allows publishers, not retailers, to control the price to the consumer. And capitulate Amazon did, quickly and publicly.
But imagine if Amazon had just been a little bit more savvy and less arrogant. The entire publishing and author community had been up in arms for months about Amazon's pricing of popular trade ebooks at $9.99 or lower, as it believed that price point to be a dangerously low precedent. It had the potential to set consumer price expectations at levels insufficient to allow the emerging ebook industry to become economically viable for all parties.
If Amazon, in the face of this rather fierce resistance, had sat down and twigged its pricing policy just a bit, perhaps even in dialogue with publishers, it could have avoided the mess it's now found itself in, of having to adopt under pressure a business model that was invented by Apple and runs entirely counter to Amazon's whole discount, value for money, consumer-friendly proposition.
It's been left to Apple to shoehorn publishers, bang some sense into them, and come up with a pricing model or template that now seems to have informed the whole industry, an industry which was all over the place in pricing philosophies prior to this. Apple's template is this:
Print edition under $22.00 = $9.99 or less
$22.01-$24.00 = $10.99 or less
$24.01-$25.00 = $11.99 or less
$25.01-$27.50 = $12.99 or less
$27.51-$30.00 = $14.99 or less
$30.01-$35.00 = $16.99 or less
$35.01-$40.00 = $19.99 or less
It's roughly a 50% discount off the print edition price. Was that beyond the wit of Amazon to come up with, and sell to publishers as the way that both parties should price? And could not Amazon, in return for publishers lowering their ebook RRP's to these levels, have agreed to accept a lower discount than the 50% they previously demanded - to, say, 30%? This would have preserved the wholesale model, where the retailer, not the publisher sets the ultimate price to the consumer, as it should be. Retailers know consumer dynamics intimately. Publishers don't. Retailers need the freedom to construct promotions and special offers around price, and all parties, including consumers, benefit from these. Publishers are hopeless at this sort of stuff.
Amazon stuffed up, lost control, and are now scurrying around like a dog with its tail between its legs. It's not a pretty sight. They utterly misread the anger in the publishing and author community.
What a strategic blunder.
However I'm amazed that serious commentators on publishing matters in the US have not come out and condemned the agency model for the profound abomination that it really is. It breaches some fairly fundamental, age old distribution and retail practices, as well as being essentially anti-consumer. I can't see it being sustainable over the medium to longer term. It's a ball and chain ankle bracelet which the trade should not have acquiesced to.
Monday, February 22, 2010
Stumbling Backwards Into the Future: ebooks and Territorial Copyright
Right now book lovers around the world are being utterly antagonised. This is happening for the following reasons:
- Territorial rights are being bought for the 'Work', which is inclusive of all formats. This is right and proper and really shouldn't operate in any other way. Calls by literary agents and author associations for authors to withhold e-rights from traditional print publishers are wrong-headed and, like most things that essentially don't make sense in the real world, will quickly come to nothing.
- But publishers are falling into the mistake of running ebooks along the same familiar tracks as print books when it comes to exploiting these geographic rights. Whereas print books are invariably re-issued in the specific territorial edition, ebooks do not need, and shouldn't therefore be press-ganged into, the same analogue dynamic.
- There is no need at all to 'issue' the ebook into a different territorial edition. All that needs to happen is that the revenue collected for sales into the appropriate territory OF THE ORIGINAL EBOOK needs to be now remitted BY THE ORIGINAL EBOOK PUBLISHER to the publisher who has bought the rights to that territory. There need be no cessation in supply. Amazon, Apple, B&N, Google, whoever, can provide sales data by territory. Amazon does that now for print books.
- What is currently happening is quite absurd, utterly unnecessary and is alienating readers. Let's take a typical example: if a work, in simultaneous print and ebook editions, is first published in the US, then the ebook (barring any silly 'windowing' or withholding policy) is usually available globally, but only until that publisher or the author's agent sells Commonwealth rights. Then it suddenly, and infuriatingly, STOPS being available outside the US, and this state of affairs lasts for months and months while the Commonwealth publisher (my god how that term grates!) ambles up and publishes its own ebook edition.
- UK and Australian publishers have felt little urgency in releasing their ebook territorial versions, as the installed base of ebook readers has been, and still is, quite small. Why rush in and possibly undermine sales of the more expensive print book? Thankfully, over the next year or so we will see this dramatically change. The demand for the ebook will need to be satisfied.
- This is why Australian Kindle owners are so frustrated by not having available to them tens of thousands of ebook titles that are freely available to Americans. The same with Apple Apps. It is all so unnecessary. The mechanics of rights sales, production, versioning, etc, are not the problem. The barrier is conceptual.
- Which bring me to my final observation about how all this is playing out. It is extremely frustrating to me that e-wholesalers and e-retailers like Amazon, Apple, Kobo, etc are willingly partnering with publishers in this backwards stumble into the future. Unlike for printed books, these new world, glitzy digital entities are refusing to supply whole swathes of global consumers because of restrictive, geographic covenants they've entered into with publishers, that force them to honor territorial deals publishers do with each other. It's a clear breach of common and accepted retail practice. Don't get me wrong: publishers are right to do the deals. But retailers are wrong to withhold supply to their customers on the basis of a crass, geographic discrimination.
- It's even worse than allowing publishers to take away from you the power of pricing by forcing you onto an 'agency' model of supply (shame on you Amazon, for your degrading capitulation to Macmillan). That bad publishing strategy will soon come unstuck I'm sure. Give it a couple of years at the most. Publishers have no business dictating pricing to retailers. (It's quite illegal in Australia anyway, thank god!)
- The question for readers is: how long do we have to wait for publishers to focus primarily on the needs of consumers and work out a sensible path into the future, one free of awkward, analogue dead ends and blockages that have no place on the celesial highway?
Tuesday, February 16, 2010
An Old Idea But Still a Bad One
SUPPORT FOR AUSTRALIA’S BOOK INDUSTRY IN THE DIGITAL AGE
The Rudd Labor Government is establishing a new Book Industry Strategy Group to help Australia’s $1.5 billion book industry meet the challenges of increased online book sales and grasp the opportunities presented by the emerging ebook market.
The strategy group will bring together representatives from across the industry to map out the way forward for this important sector. It will develop strategies to address the key issues of supply chain integration and developing viable business models for the digital age.
Announcing the strategy group at the Digital Revolution: Publishing in the 21st Century symposium in Melbourne today, Innovation Minister Senator Kim Carr said it will focus on collaboration, transformation and future sustainability.
“The written word may be almost as old as human civilisation itself but this doesn’t mean we can ignore the very real and very rapid advances being made in digital publishing technologies,” Senator Carr said.
“We are moving into an environment in which the printed book is just one platform among many.
“We have a proud and distinguished literary history in this country thanks to the work of generations of talented authors, publishers and local book manufacturers.
“Australia has the only dynamic and growing independent book selling sector in the English-speaking world.
“I want to keep it that way. We must be prepared to seize the opportunities the digital revolution is offering.
“I am giving this strategy group a very clear mandate – I don’t just want a report, I want a way forward.
“I want to see book printers, publishers, distributors and retailers together in one room collaborating with each other and taking responsibility for transforming their industry in a way that ensures its future sustainability.
“The group will be able to tap into our existing $50 million a year Enterprise Connect initiative and a broad range of other programs currently in place to assist business transformation.”
The Book Industry Strategy Group will operate according to precise terms of reference and is expected to report back within twelve months.
Having shamefully walked away late last year from the prime dynamic of industry change, progress and development - competition - the Rudd government now reverts to the oldest of bad ideas - 'industry policy', in order to offer some semblance of actual government engagement with the book industry.
Kim Carr, better known in economically liberal circles as Kim Il Carr, representing in government the remnants of Victoria's once thriving manufacturing base - unionised, organised, centralised - has long been a fevered supporter of the once fashionable but now widely discredited concept of Industry Policy, a complex framework of grants, subsidies, offsets, tax breaks, quotas, tariffs, incentives, marketing boards, mandates, etc, that were meant, when all boiled down, to provide a good level of protection to industries from the chill winds of global competition and technological disruption. Give them a helping hand, so to speak. Ensure, in today's parlance, their 'future sustainability'.
Look at the press release, interesting on a number of levels. Firstly and superficially Minister, the book industry is $2.5 billion in size, not $1.5 billion.
Secondly, why aren't the nation's authors part of this collaborative 'all together in one room' process? All other players are there: printers, publishers, distributors and retailers. And come to think of it....why not..er.. READERS?
Thirdly, Carr lauds the fact that 'Australia has the only dynamic and growing independent book selling sector in the English-speaking world', and he 'wants to keep it that way'. But he seems blithely unaware that, 'seizing the opportunities the digital revolution is offering' may very well mean a wholesale undermining of the retail bookseller. His protectionist instinct is flying in the face of reality. You can't skewer things so two opposing forces suddenly cease to oppose. The dynamics of the free market will work these things out, not noble sentiments or 'strategy groups' or any officially sanctioned 'collaborations'.
It's not hard to guess what this ominous, Roald Dahl-esque BISG will recommend. It will simply pool all the trade's current obsessions and delusions which have been articulated to the point of exquisite tedium over the last awful year. After a breathless appreciation of the government's wisdom in retaining the parallel importation restrictions, the central recommendation will undoubtedly be to impose the GST on Amazon. Then to empower the Australia Council with more money for literature and 'industry development'. Then all sorts of 'facilitation' stuff that bureaucrats love. All very deep.
Industry programs and proposals going back decades will be dusted off, given a fresh coat of paint and enthusiastically re-presented. To a government that staged a 2020 summit which elicited heaps of recommendations that have never since seen the light of day. (I wouldn't be at all surprised to see the printers re-propose the book bounty! This is Carr we're talking about...)
I'm too cynical, no doubt. But rest assured, I do know what I'm talking about.
Friday, February 5, 2010
Down Under and Anal
The Federal Court's decision that the flute riff in the classic Australian song Down Under breaches the copyright held by Larrikin Music in the iconic Australian folk song Kookaburra Sits in the Old Gumtree is quite simply appalling.
The judge found that a 'substantial part' of Kookaburra was swiped by Greg Ham for his solo, and that substantial part added up to two bars, yes, TWO BARS! Given that Kookaburra, in total, adds up to four bars, then 50% must be considered substantial.
Now no-one could object to that: 50% of anything is a substantial part.
The problem is this: when any piece of copyright content is short and brief it would be almost impossible to quote even the smallest part of it without running up against the concept of substantiality. And quoting and referencing prior works is what so much of creative output is all about. New works build on the rich legacy of others - the musical, literary, filmic, performance traditions in which they live and breathe. That tradition is enriched and extended by borrowing, tribute, echo, reflection, criticism, satire, etc.
Ham, a classically trained musician, wanted to introduce into Down Under some appropriate Australian references. Quoting two bars (remember, two bars) of a universally known and revered old Australian children's song, written in 1934, was reverential and enhanced the overall wittiness of the entire Down Under song. As well, the two bars were only a small part of the solo and an even smaller part of the song.
The judge seems to me to have missed the logic of this. It would have been impossible for Ham to have quoted less than two bars (eg, one bar) and still achieve his valid purpose - the small and enriching quotation, that had to be recognisable.
If referencing an insubstantial part therefore of such a brief piece of content is impossible, then surely the concept of substantiality in this context is bereft of meaning.
The judge has delivered a decision based on an empty technicality. It also runs totally counter to the current musical culture of sampling and remixing, and for this reason alone will stoke the fires of disaffection that are bringing the whole notion of copyright into disrepute, particularly amongst the young.
What a lost opportunity. An opportunity to be wise.
Sunday, January 31, 2010
Macmillan and Amazon
The hamfisted attempts of US publishers to force Amazon to raise its ebook prices to above US$9.99 have now descended into farce. (See Macmillan's letter to authors below)
This sort of activity is quite illegal in Australia, under our Trade Practices Act, and thank god for that. It is openly and brazenly anti-consumer. No Australian corporation can indulge in any action or strategy aimed primarily at forcing a retailer on price.
We get a few things right in this country, we really do.
To: All Macmillan authors/illustrators and the literary agent community
From: John Sargent
This past Thursday I met with Amazon in Seattle. I gave them our proposal for new terms of sale for e books under the agency model which will become effective in early March. In addition, I told them they could stay with their old terms of sale, but that this would involve extensive and deep windowing of titles. By the time I arrived back in New York late yesterday afternoon they informed me that they were taking all our books off the Kindle site, and off Amazon. The books will continue to be available on Amazon.com through third parties.
I regret that we have reached this impasse. Amazon has been a valuable customer for a long time, and it is my great hope that they will continue to be in the very near future. They have been a great innovator in our industry, and I suspect they will continue to be for decades to come.
It is those decades that concern me now, as I am sure they concern you. In the ink-on-paper world we sell books to retailers far and wide on a business model that provides a level playing field, and allows all retailers the possibility of selling books profitably. Looking to the future and to a growing digital business, we need to establish the same sort of business model, one that encourages new devices and new stores. One that encourages healthy competition. One that is stable and rational. It also needs to insure that intellectual property can be widely available digitally at a price that is both fair to the consumer and allows those who create it and publish it to be fairly compensated.
Under the agency model, we will sell the digital editions of our books to consumers through our retailers. Our retailers will act as our agents and will take a 30% commission (the standard split today for many digital media businesses). The price will be set for each book individually. Our plan is to price the digital edition of most adult trade books in a price range from $14.99 to $5.99. At first release, concurrent with a hardcover, most titles will be priced between $14.99 and $12.99. E books will almost always appear day on date with the physical edition. Pricing will be dynamic over time.
The agency model would allow Amazon to make more money selling our books, not less. We would make less money in our dealings with Amazon under the new model. Our disagreement is not about short-term profitability but rather about the long-term viability and stability of the digital book market.
Amazon and Macmillan both want a healthy and vibrant future for books. We clearly do not agree on how to get there. Meanwhile, the action they chose to take last night clearly defines the importance they attribute to their view. We hold our view equally strongly. I hope you agree with us.
You are a vast and wonderful crew. It is impossible to reach you all in the very limited timeframe we are working under, so I have sent this message in unorthodox form. I hope it reaches you all, and quickly. Monday morning I will fully brief all of our editors, and they will be able to answer your questions. I hope to speak to many of you over the coming days.
Thanks for all the support you have shown in the last few hours; it is much appreciated.
All best,
John
This sort of activity is quite illegal in Australia, under our Trade Practices Act, and thank god for that. It is openly and brazenly anti-consumer. No Australian corporation can indulge in any action or strategy aimed primarily at forcing a retailer on price.
We get a few things right in this country, we really do.
To: All Macmillan authors/illustrators and the literary agent community
From: John Sargent
This past Thursday I met with Amazon in Seattle. I gave them our proposal for new terms of sale for e books under the agency model which will become effective in early March. In addition, I told them they could stay with their old terms of sale, but that this would involve extensive and deep windowing of titles. By the time I arrived back in New York late yesterday afternoon they informed me that they were taking all our books off the Kindle site, and off Amazon. The books will continue to be available on Amazon.com through third parties.
I regret that we have reached this impasse. Amazon has been a valuable customer for a long time, and it is my great hope that they will continue to be in the very near future. They have been a great innovator in our industry, and I suspect they will continue to be for decades to come.
It is those decades that concern me now, as I am sure they concern you. In the ink-on-paper world we sell books to retailers far and wide on a business model that provides a level playing field, and allows all retailers the possibility of selling books profitably. Looking to the future and to a growing digital business, we need to establish the same sort of business model, one that encourages new devices and new stores. One that encourages healthy competition. One that is stable and rational. It also needs to insure that intellectual property can be widely available digitally at a price that is both fair to the consumer and allows those who create it and publish it to be fairly compensated.
Under the agency model, we will sell the digital editions of our books to consumers through our retailers. Our retailers will act as our agents and will take a 30% commission (the standard split today for many digital media businesses). The price will be set for each book individually. Our plan is to price the digital edition of most adult trade books in a price range from $14.99 to $5.99. At first release, concurrent with a hardcover, most titles will be priced between $14.99 and $12.99. E books will almost always appear day on date with the physical edition. Pricing will be dynamic over time.
The agency model would allow Amazon to make more money selling our books, not less. We would make less money in our dealings with Amazon under the new model. Our disagreement is not about short-term profitability but rather about the long-term viability and stability of the digital book market.
Amazon and Macmillan both want a healthy and vibrant future for books. We clearly do not agree on how to get there. Meanwhile, the action they chose to take last night clearly defines the importance they attribute to their view. We hold our view equally strongly. I hope you agree with us.
You are a vast and wonderful crew. It is impossible to reach you all in the very limited timeframe we are working under, so I have sent this message in unorthodox form. I hope it reaches you all, and quickly. Monday morning I will fully brief all of our editors, and they will be able to answer your questions. I hope to speak to many of you over the coming days.
Thanks for all the support you have shown in the last few hours; it is much appreciated.
All best,
John
Friday, January 29, 2010
More iPad: quite simply it is way too big!
I think I'm on fairly safe ground in predicting that Apple's new iPad will never make it as an eReader that competes with the Kindle. It's just TOO BIG!
No humungous device like this has any chance whatsoever of capturing a sizable share of the standard trade ebook market. Amazon can rest easy. Can you imagine consumers lugging this thing around just to read Dan Brown in a cafe, on a small wobbly table which can barely cope with a coffee and a Danish now?
I was eagerly anticipating the iPad as I imagined it would be roughly the same size as the Kindle but with far more screen real estate; and in color; and web-enabled. One of the Kindle's biggest design flaws for me is the fact that the keyboard takes up far too much room at the bottom, thus making the actual screen far too small. I use the keyboard infrequently - it's only a search function - but of course read from the screen constantly. The entry hall of a house shouldn't be the same size as the living room! No sense there.
The iPad will most probably become a niche device, used by sales reps for product presentations, etc, much as existing tablets are now. But it is in the textbook space that the real revolution will take place. Content combined with interactivity and communication: that's the textbook future. Most students in five years time will be lugging around iPads instead of laptops, and certainly instead of textbooks.
So there is still a space in the market for a multi-functional ebook reader that is actually aimed at the ordinary consumer who goes to a cafe, travels on public transport, and flies in planes. It ain't gonna be the iPad.
Thursday, January 28, 2010
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)





