The ebook debate is becoming very confusing, with all sorts of people saying all sorts of things.
The only way to cut through and get some clear perspective is to do what strategists should always do, that is, see it through the eyes of the customer. Be CUSTOMER-CENTRIC. It's not easy but it's essential.
As a new consumer of ebooks, here's an early stab at what I would like to see:
1. Simultaneous publication with the first version of the print book.
Some major US publishers are getting spooked by Amazon, and delaying their ebook release dates for a few months. They're trying to protect print edition sales from being undercut by Amazon's nasty $9.99 price. Instead of seeing hundreds of thousands of new and enthusiastic Kindle owners as an opportunity they're seeing them as a threat, because some of those enthusiasts would purchase the print book if the ebook weren't available. Some. Maybe 25-30%? Let's do the math:
Print revenues without the ebook available: 10,000 x $15.00 net = $150,000.
Print revenues with the ebook also available: 7,000 x $15.00 net = $105,000
ebook revenues: 3,500 x $12.00 net = $42,000
(I've assumed ebook sales to be 50% of the print book sales if both versions were available, as Amazon seems to be suggesting this is their current, for now at least, sales ratio).
So you can see revenues are pretty much the same under both scenarios.
2. ebook prices should be lower than the initial print version by 30% at least, and then decreased sequentially just as print books are now.
Let's look at what the customer doesn't get by purchasing an ebook: a well-designed and printed package which incudes an arresting, beautiful cover; something to place on a bookshelf for all to see and pick up for years and years; something to lend to family and friends; something to sell second hand; a felt sense of where you are and how much further you've got to go - the standard 'flick' thing. What you get instead is just the content, in a standard typeface, with clumsy accessibility. It's a pared down, decontextualised experience, well and truly.
What I'd dearly like to see, and would be willing to pay extra for, would be the ability to purchase a 'print and ebook combined' package at my favorite terrestrial bookstore. If I could buy the printed version of Wolf Hall and get the ebook version thrown in for either free or another five bucks, that would be wonderful. That would entail a partnership agreement between the bookseller, the publisher and Amazon, so that when I walked out of the shop I carried the thick-as-a-brick paper version and knew that the ebook version was sitting snugly in my Kindle. A real 'home and away' package!
Regarding prices, there is a great deal of confusion in the industry on this subject. There's this quite silly notion that the ebook has to be the same price for all time. Rubbish. The whole point of sequencing cheaper versions of print books, from the initial hardback, to the trade paperback, through to the mass market paperback, is to make the book available, in an orderly fashion, to wider markets at lower prices. People don't want the mass market paperback - they want the mass market price. Ebooks therefore, where no printing costs have to be lowered accordingly to protect margins, can also undergo a lower price process. In the first year of publication they could be 70% or so of the hardback price, in the second year 50%, and finally 30%, or some such gradation. Not all books have to follow this tradey sequence of course, but many do. You can't have a situation where the ebook is $10.00 and the paperback $8.00. (I'm talking US dollars here, as this is where the debate is. We're a long way from the action in Australia, unfortunately, and will be until local titles are readily available on the Kindle, the iPhone and then all the others).
3. Choice should be part of the standard offer.
Publishers should stop seeing the so-called 'enhanced ebook' as part of the pricing solution, as in 'Throw in some audio, video and added extras and we can charge more and solve our revenue problems'. As a customer I want to be able to chose - either the basic or enhanced version, or a print/ebook combination, or some other appealing package.
So in summary, publishers should embrace this new market aggressively and optimistically, and stop being scared witless and defensive. Focus on readers and customers and their needs and preferences. As for Australian publishers, for god's sake get off your bums and get on with it.
Thursday, January 21, 2010
Wednesday, January 20, 2010
Game Change and Clueless Publishers
Obama's run for the White House was always going to going to be a ripe subject for an intriguing, behind the scenes, tell-all political tome. Game Change is definitely it. Published in the US by HarperCollins and re-titled, stupidly, by Penguin as Race of a Lifetime for those of us in the British Commonwealth who couldn't possibly relate to 'Game Change' as a title, it's an absolutely fascinating read for political junkies of all sorts.
Some observations:
First, well done Penguin Australia for getting the book out on virtually the same day (Jan 11) as the US release, and for pricing it competitvely ($32.95 for 448pp, which is today's exchange plus 10% plus GST plus price point rounding, which is the fair formula).
Second, a book like this, which pulls no punches and is full of some really unpleasant revelations about so many of the major and minor players in the Democratic and Republican campaigns, could never have been published in Australia about Australian politicians because of our restrictive defamation laws.
Third, changing the title for the Commonwealth edition virtually guarantees the book doesn't capitalise on the huge publicity Game Change is getting in the world's media. I stumbled on it in Readings by accident when I was actually looking for the title Game Change, and thinking I'd probably, once again, have to go to Amazon. As will so many other junkies.
And finally, what a mess HarperCollins have made of the ebook. They're delaying the release for six weeks so as not to allow Amazon's $9.99 price to undercut hard cover sales. This is causing a consumer revolt, as it should. Clueless in the extreme. No respect for consumer choice. This is how traditional publishing will die.
Some observations:
First, well done Penguin Australia for getting the book out on virtually the same day (Jan 11) as the US release, and for pricing it competitvely ($32.95 for 448pp, which is today's exchange plus 10% plus GST plus price point rounding, which is the fair formula).
Second, a book like this, which pulls no punches and is full of some really unpleasant revelations about so many of the major and minor players in the Democratic and Republican campaigns, could never have been published in Australia about Australian politicians because of our restrictive defamation laws.
Third, changing the title for the Commonwealth edition virtually guarantees the book doesn't capitalise on the huge publicity Game Change is getting in the world's media. I stumbled on it in Readings by accident when I was actually looking for the title Game Change, and thinking I'd probably, once again, have to go to Amazon. As will so many other junkies.
And finally, what a mess HarperCollins have made of the ebook. They're delaying the release for six weeks so as not to allow Amazon's $9.99 price to undercut hard cover sales. This is causing a consumer revolt, as it should. Clueless in the extreme. No respect for consumer choice. This is how traditional publishing will die.
Wednesday, December 16, 2009
Amazon and ebooks: a Dialogue
The rise and rise of Amazon: prepare for the battle.
Rachael McDiarmid:
In the past few days several US publishers have announced they will be delaying the release of e-book versions of major releases. So what does Amazon do? Well, instead of selling for the already loss-leading price of US$9.99, let's take it even lower to $7.99!!! Let's show the publishers exactly who is in charge of this ebook market. Let's offer Under the Dome by Stephen King and Going Rogue by Sarah Palin for $7.99. The hardcover for the latter is listed on Amazon as US$28.99 slashed 50% to US$14.50. Slash it by half again if you want the ebook. Bestsellers are being slashed - Stephenie Meyer's first two Twilight books for US$4.25, Stieg Larsson's The Girl Who Played with Fire at US$7.99. Slash Slash and Slash again.
What happens next? Well surprise surprise, Barnes and Noble cut their ebook prices to match. I'm now waiting to see what Sony does. They've already admitted the US$9.99 price is NOT PROFITABLE. You can read the full article here. Yet I'm taking bets as to when they'll slash their prices! Any takers?
But back to the giant that is Amazon. I know some publishers are trying to wrestle control away from them so they can control their own ebook destinies. Can't everyone see these price points are DEVALUING the product and the whole reading experience? And what about profitability folks? It's already fragile in the bookselling and publishing industry.
It's no use discussing what percentage Amazon, Sony, Scribd etc take on ebook sales. We already know Amazon is using their pricing strategies to make the Kindle the ereader of choice, to build market share and customer loyalty. Sony has pretty much admited the same. They invest in the technology, they need people to buy it.
While publishers benefit from the lower ebook prices in the short term (through higher sales), according to Mike Shatzkin they "don't trust Amazon to keep things that way. From their perspective, Amazon is building a consumer expectation of an under-$10 price point while they are building up their audience of captive Kindle consumers. How long can it be, publishers figure, before Amazon says 'sorry, now you have to sell me these for under ten dollars?'" Mike also shared his thoughts on the possible war over the issue, including publishers not supplying or selling e-books through Amazon, Amazon suppressing the sale of their printed books, and more.
So when and where will the battle lines be drawn? It's a'comin, folks. Wait and see...
Peter Donoughue:
Frankly, I don't think there's an issue here Rachael, apart from the entirely normal one of a retail behemoth flexing its muscles (yawn).
Publishers should relax. And Mike Shatzkin, who has always been wary of Amazon, has it wrong too. Retailers will do what retailers always do - fight for market share. Amazon wants to make it hard for Barnes and Noble and their new nook, and others, and what's wrong with that?
The real story here is how publishers are getting their strategy wrong, by delaying ebook releases. Publishers Lunch had a nice dialogue on this this morning, with top publishers all agreeing delaying makes sense: 'It's like delaying the paperback release - no different'....
This doesn't make sense. It IS different - very different. We're not talking about print dynamics, with their traditional print audiences. We're talking a new digital paradigm, with a new customer dynamic, that needs to be respected. These customers resent waiting. They don't wait weeks for the SMH to put a major story on their website just to force punters to buy the printed paper. How absurd!
Rachael McDiarmid:
In the past few days several US publishers have announced they will be delaying the release of e-book versions of major releases. So what does Amazon do? Well, instead of selling for the already loss-leading price of US$9.99, let's take it even lower to $7.99!!! Let's show the publishers exactly who is in charge of this ebook market. Let's offer Under the Dome by Stephen King and Going Rogue by Sarah Palin for $7.99. The hardcover for the latter is listed on Amazon as US$28.99 slashed 50% to US$14.50. Slash it by half again if you want the ebook. Bestsellers are being slashed - Stephenie Meyer's first two Twilight books for US$4.25, Stieg Larsson's The Girl Who Played with Fire at US$7.99. Slash Slash and Slash again.
What happens next? Well surprise surprise, Barnes and Noble cut their ebook prices to match. I'm now waiting to see what Sony does. They've already admitted the US$9.99 price is NOT PROFITABLE. You can read the full article here. Yet I'm taking bets as to when they'll slash their prices! Any takers?
But back to the giant that is Amazon. I know some publishers are trying to wrestle control away from them so they can control their own ebook destinies. Can't everyone see these price points are DEVALUING the product and the whole reading experience? And what about profitability folks? It's already fragile in the bookselling and publishing industry.
It's no use discussing what percentage Amazon, Sony, Scribd etc take on ebook sales. We already know Amazon is using their pricing strategies to make the Kindle the ereader of choice, to build market share and customer loyalty. Sony has pretty much admited the same. They invest in the technology, they need people to buy it.
While publishers benefit from the lower ebook prices in the short term (through higher sales), according to Mike Shatzkin they "don't trust Amazon to keep things that way. From their perspective, Amazon is building a consumer expectation of an under-$10 price point while they are building up their audience of captive Kindle consumers. How long can it be, publishers figure, before Amazon says 'sorry, now you have to sell me these for under ten dollars?'" Mike also shared his thoughts on the possible war over the issue, including publishers not supplying or selling e-books through Amazon, Amazon suppressing the sale of their printed books, and more.
So when and where will the battle lines be drawn? It's a'comin, folks. Wait and see...
Peter Donoughue:
Frankly, I don't think there's an issue here Rachael, apart from the entirely normal one of a retail behemoth flexing its muscles (yawn).
Publishers should relax. And Mike Shatzkin, who has always been wary of Amazon, has it wrong too. Retailers will do what retailers always do - fight for market share. Amazon wants to make it hard for Barnes and Noble and their new nook, and others, and what's wrong with that?
The real story here is how publishers are getting their strategy wrong, by delaying ebook releases. Publishers Lunch had a nice dialogue on this this morning, with top publishers all agreeing delaying makes sense: 'It's like delaying the paperback release - no different'....
This doesn't make sense. It IS different - very different. We're not talking about print dynamics, with their traditional print audiences. We're talking a new digital paradigm, with a new customer dynamic, that needs to be respected. These customers resent waiting. They don't wait weeks for the SMH to put a major story on their website just to force punters to buy the printed paper. How absurd!
Saturday, November 28, 2009
Amazon and the GST

I've said it plenty of times before, and I'll say it again: calls by Australian publishers and booksellers for the government to force Amazon to charge GST to Australian customers are profoundly misplaced. As a government policy it would be just plain bad.
Here are the reasons:
1. It would dampen the pressure on publishers to keep their markups on imported titles reasonable and competitive. (And the government have relied on this pressure as a justification for not tampering with the parallel importation restrictions).
2. Booksellers should welcome this pressure, not lobby to weaken it. The most effective way for booksellers to compete with Amazon is through ramping up the pressure on publishers to be more competitive on pricing, delivery and trading terms, and certainly not by (once again!) supporting publishers in their efforts to be protected from it.
3. I'm not an accountant or tax expert, but I'm sure it's relevant that the GST is a value-added tax, not a consumption tax or sales tax. So businesses have to be in the Australian value chain to be able to deal with it administratively and financially. Businesses that charge the tax receive input tax credits for the GST charged all the way through their supply chain. Overseas businesses supplying direct to consumers are, by definition, not in the supply loop. Nor are they subject to Australian law. This is why calls to 'slap a GST on Amazon like US states that impose their sales taxes', are naive. It's apples and oranges. If ever Amazon sets up a distribution centre in Australia, that's when they'll be forced to charge GST.
4. The Rudd government has just decided that Amazon is the savior - a friend of booksellers, printers, authors, readers, because of the pressure it puts on publishers to ratchet up their performance. So does the industry really think the government will now agree to protect publishers from that competitive rod up their arse?
5. Booksellers have one huge advantage in competing against Amazon - they don't have to charge freight. If that sizable impost doesn't currently deter Australians from purchasing from Amazon, then an additional 10% GST won't make one skerrick of difference, and is frequently washed away by currently fluctuations anyway. Why do booksellers keep banging on about this? Go to the publishers instead and bang on about the need for better, more responsive terms. That would be entirely productive.
6. It's simply not a good look for the trade to be arguing that book buyers should be lumped with another tax. And it's not a good look to keep arguing in Canberra for additional protection. Talk of 'levelling the playing field' is a dead give-away. It's how rent-seekers frame it.
It really is time the book trade grew up, and began to focus on the real issues facing it. There is so much that could be done if all parties stopped being distracted and absorbed by ephemera.
Saturday, November 14, 2009
The Big Lie...again!
I referred in my last post to the Big Lie perpetrated by publishers and authors in the parallel importation debate. Here is a succinct expression of it. It was published in Crikey yesterday:
'Patrick Gallagher, Chairman, Allen and Unwin, writes:
A combination of naiveté and muddled thinking from Crikey in the Great Book Debate. Blind Freddie can surely see the motivation behind the Murdoch Press's rabid publisher bashing, which is simply a case of a handy stick to take to Rudd. Which in fact makes the Government's decision to retain Territorial Copyright the brave one; it would have been far easier to take the populist line, tear down the walls and proclaim cheap books for all.
Put those pesky intellectuals back in their place and give the people lots of cheap rubbish from overseas.
Don't fall for the economists' and free marketeers' attempts to paint this as a failed opportunity to create a nirvana for the reading public. The small but noisy minority led by Dymocks and Bob Carr had one thing and one thing only in mind - better margins for their business.
The government deserves credit for appreciating this, and for understanding the wholesale damage that change to copyright would do to the book industry, to authors and ultimately consumers'.
The Government's decision 'to retain territorial copyright'? That wasn't the government's decision at all! The government decided to retain the importation restrictions. THESE HAVE NOTHING WHATSOEVER TO DO WITH TERRITORIAL COPYRIGHT! (See my speech to the Copyright Society on October 17 on this blog for a explication of this issue).
It really pains me to see seasoned industry players not even at first base in their understanding of these issues after almost 20 years.
'Patrick Gallagher, Chairman, Allen and Unwin, writes:
A combination of naiveté and muddled thinking from Crikey in the Great Book Debate. Blind Freddie can surely see the motivation behind the Murdoch Press's rabid publisher bashing, which is simply a case of a handy stick to take to Rudd. Which in fact makes the Government's decision to retain Territorial Copyright the brave one; it would have been far easier to take the populist line, tear down the walls and proclaim cheap books for all.
Put those pesky intellectuals back in their place and give the people lots of cheap rubbish from overseas.
Don't fall for the economists' and free marketeers' attempts to paint this as a failed opportunity to create a nirvana for the reading public. The small but noisy minority led by Dymocks and Bob Carr had one thing and one thing only in mind - better margins for their business.
The government deserves credit for appreciating this, and for understanding the wholesale damage that change to copyright would do to the book industry, to authors and ultimately consumers'.
The Government's decision 'to retain territorial copyright'? That wasn't the government's decision at all! The government decided to retain the importation restrictions. THESE HAVE NOTHING WHATSOEVER TO DO WITH TERRITORIAL COPYRIGHT! (See my speech to the Copyright Society on October 17 on this blog for a explication of this issue).
It really pains me to see seasoned industry players not even at first base in their understanding of these issues after almost 20 years.
Thursday, November 12, 2009
Why the Booksellers Comprehensively Lost.
When the history of the parallel importation debate is written, as I'm certain it one day will be, what with so many publishing courses and academics sprouting like mushrooms across the country in recent years, there will be a judgement made on precisely why the nation's booksellers, big and small, chain and independent, got this debate so profoundly wrong, ill-judged the political zeitgeist, and so comprehensively lost on every conceivable front.
Even given that the Rudd government gave up and played dead on the issue, which is not stopping the APA from insufferably championing its campaign winning brilliance, the booksellers, both the ABA and Dymocks, misjudged their fundamental strategy and therefore tactics so badly that the sorry saga needs to be recorded by an expert commentator such as myself before the caravan moves relentlessly on and we all get back to business.
1. The campaign run by the authors and publishers was based on a Big Lie (not an intentional one, so it would be more accurately labelled a 'big untruth', but that phrase has no poetry or power so let's stick with lie). The central thesis was that it was all about maintaining territorial copyright in Australia, because without it this great and successful industry would collapse.
2. The ABA and particularly its independent bookseller members swallowed this lie hook, line and sinker. I remember the sheer terror I felt when the booksellers, at various meetings around the country last year when the issue first arose, decided to support this publisher thesis and ditch their previously long-held position in support of a deregulated, open market. There was also a misguided belief that any gains from abolition of the restrictions would go mostly to the hated chains who could flex their purchasing muscle to gain more competitive advantage over the little guys.
3. This blog is littered with references to this 'sublime delusion', much to the chagrin of many of my bookseller friends. But the fact is the ABA's adoption of this posture hamstrung them from day one and neutered them in the unfolding political campaign.
4. The one sad fact of this campaign was that the lie was never nailed. Never ever nailed, except by me, a lone, irrelevant and pretty irritating voice. But imagine what could have been, if the ABA, united with Dymocks, had focused their energies in the media, in Canberra and elsewhere on nailing the lie, the absurdity and illogicality of the publishers' line.
5. Every crazy utterance could have been pounced on, and there were literally hundreds of them through the course of the debate. The madness of the printers, for example. Of all the nonsensical propositions put forward the printers' fantasies were some of the most exquisite. But the ABA never had the enemy in its sights. It never even knew who the enemy was.
6. As for Dymocks, what a mess. Their campaign was built around the premise of 'cheaper books' for western suburbs' punters. But they never nailed the lie, didn't even see it. Thus their campaign had no power or momentum. You can't position yourself as an enemy of culture and win any debate in Canberra. You just can't. Because you make it way too hard for the politicians. If you're demanding they nix a thriving and vital cultural industry you've lost them totally. Dymocks had to nail the lie, but they didn't.
7. The APA ran a superb campaign - focused, passionate, constantly on message, and very simple: preserve what we have or see a vital cultural industry die: It's all about preserving territorial copyright. There's the lie right there. And where are the voices saying it isn't so? Even the Productivity Commission was sucked in. It refused to engage and argue this point. In my memorable phrase it endlessly quoted submissions articulating the lie, but left them on the page 'like stinking turds'. It made itself utterly vulnerable.
8. In the final stages of the campaign the ABA and Dymocks, scenting defeat, came up with a compromise plan which was full of holes and could not possibly get up, as I explained in recent blog posts. You just can't propose something that breaches international treaties on one hand, and is utterly impractical in the real world on the other. This was a real low point.
9. Now the booksellers are lamenting the lost opportunity. They should be celebrating what they campaigned for - continuing protection; the continuance of 'territorial copyright' - but they must know they got it wrong right from the start. They are also promising to continue the fight. Oh please! IT'S OVER!
Even given that the Rudd government gave up and played dead on the issue, which is not stopping the APA from insufferably championing its campaign winning brilliance, the booksellers, both the ABA and Dymocks, misjudged their fundamental strategy and therefore tactics so badly that the sorry saga needs to be recorded by an expert commentator such as myself before the caravan moves relentlessly on and we all get back to business.
1. The campaign run by the authors and publishers was based on a Big Lie (not an intentional one, so it would be more accurately labelled a 'big untruth', but that phrase has no poetry or power so let's stick with lie). The central thesis was that it was all about maintaining territorial copyright in Australia, because without it this great and successful industry would collapse.
2. The ABA and particularly its independent bookseller members swallowed this lie hook, line and sinker. I remember the sheer terror I felt when the booksellers, at various meetings around the country last year when the issue first arose, decided to support this publisher thesis and ditch their previously long-held position in support of a deregulated, open market. There was also a misguided belief that any gains from abolition of the restrictions would go mostly to the hated chains who could flex their purchasing muscle to gain more competitive advantage over the little guys.
3. This blog is littered with references to this 'sublime delusion', much to the chagrin of many of my bookseller friends. But the fact is the ABA's adoption of this posture hamstrung them from day one and neutered them in the unfolding political campaign.
4. The one sad fact of this campaign was that the lie was never nailed. Never ever nailed, except by me, a lone, irrelevant and pretty irritating voice. But imagine what could have been, if the ABA, united with Dymocks, had focused their energies in the media, in Canberra and elsewhere on nailing the lie, the absurdity and illogicality of the publishers' line.
5. Every crazy utterance could have been pounced on, and there were literally hundreds of them through the course of the debate. The madness of the printers, for example. Of all the nonsensical propositions put forward the printers' fantasies were some of the most exquisite. But the ABA never had the enemy in its sights. It never even knew who the enemy was.
6. As for Dymocks, what a mess. Their campaign was built around the premise of 'cheaper books' for western suburbs' punters. But they never nailed the lie, didn't even see it. Thus their campaign had no power or momentum. You can't position yourself as an enemy of culture and win any debate in Canberra. You just can't. Because you make it way too hard for the politicians. If you're demanding they nix a thriving and vital cultural industry you've lost them totally. Dymocks had to nail the lie, but they didn't.
7. The APA ran a superb campaign - focused, passionate, constantly on message, and very simple: preserve what we have or see a vital cultural industry die: It's all about preserving territorial copyright. There's the lie right there. And where are the voices saying it isn't so? Even the Productivity Commission was sucked in. It refused to engage and argue this point. In my memorable phrase it endlessly quoted submissions articulating the lie, but left them on the page 'like stinking turds'. It made itself utterly vulnerable.
8. In the final stages of the campaign the ABA and Dymocks, scenting defeat, came up with a compromise plan which was full of holes and could not possibly get up, as I explained in recent blog posts. You just can't propose something that breaches international treaties on one hand, and is utterly impractical in the real world on the other. This was a real low point.
9. Now the booksellers are lamenting the lost opportunity. They should be celebrating what they campaigned for - continuing protection; the continuance of 'territorial copyright' - but they must know they got it wrong right from the start. They are also promising to continue the fight. Oh please! IT'S OVER!
Wednesday, November 11, 2009
'Governing This Country is All Too Hard': Rudd
What a miserable waste of everyone's time!
The Rudd government has decided not to reform Australia's book importation regime - at all. Not even the teeniest bit of modernisation. Not even reducing the 90 days on the backlist to 30 days that every party in the industry expected and would have welcomed.
It's almost as if they've discovered Amazon in the last twelve months and concluded 'well, that's let us off the hook! We don't have to think, we don't have to debate, we don't have to upset anyone, we'll just sit back now and luxuriate in the accolades of the nation's authors. Productivity and economics can go to buggery. Basically, governing this country is all too hard'.
I'm flabbergasted! But at least I take comfort from the fact that I did predict it, fifteen months ago when this debate started:
'All of this [the author and publisher claims] is nonsense of course, but it is highly effective politically. No arid report or recommendation from an economic body like the Productivity Commission is going to be able to dislodge these noble sentiments from any politician's breast. So my strong sense is that the reform initiative will falter and the 30/90 day provisions remain'. (LOGOS 19/3, 2008)
The Rudd government has decided not to reform Australia's book importation regime - at all. Not even the teeniest bit of modernisation. Not even reducing the 90 days on the backlist to 30 days that every party in the industry expected and would have welcomed.
It's almost as if they've discovered Amazon in the last twelve months and concluded 'well, that's let us off the hook! We don't have to think, we don't have to debate, we don't have to upset anyone, we'll just sit back now and luxuriate in the accolades of the nation's authors. Productivity and economics can go to buggery. Basically, governing this country is all too hard'.
I'm flabbergasted! But at least I take comfort from the fact that I did predict it, fifteen months ago when this debate started:
'All of this [the author and publisher claims] is nonsense of course, but it is highly effective politically. No arid report or recommendation from an economic body like the Productivity Commission is going to be able to dislodge these noble sentiments from any politician's breast. So my strong sense is that the reform initiative will falter and the 30/90 day provisions remain'. (LOGOS 19/3, 2008)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


