Wednesday, October 28, 2009
The ABA/Dymocks flawed compromise on parallel importation
They want both the 30 day and 90 time frames reduced to seven days.
And they want a price cap policy to be introduced, as exists in Canada (which regulates a maximum 'exchange plus 10%' mark-up).
No matter how many times I've pointed out to both parties, in writing and in person, that both propositions are legally and economically non-starters for Australia, it seems they persist. Some dogs simply can't be put down.
Firstly, the seven days notion: Let me put this as clearly as I can - IT.CONTRAVENES.THE.BERNE.CONVENTION! (See my post of Sept 30 for the exact wording and rationale of Berne's 30 days definition of simultaneous publication).
It's no surprise to me that the ABA has fallen into this trap of seeing the 30 days time frame as some sort of old fashioned relic of analogue shipping times. Well, persuade all the Berne signatories and get it changed there (good luck!), but don't continue to bang on about something that has absolutely no chance of getting up in Australian law. For the same reason that the idea of protecting only 'Australian editions', favored by David Gaunt and Mark Rubbo over the years, has consistently failed the Berne test, so this seven days proposal is a dead cat swinging in the breeze.
As for the Canadian price cap idea: on importation issues Canada is a vastly different place than Australia for one simple reason: it borders the United States. That vast economy is geographically adjacent. This means that the default position of Canadian booksellers is to import direct from the huge publishing and wholesaler warehouses in New Jersey, and get supplies shipped in virtually overnight, at US prices with no markups, and with freight costs similar to Sydney to Melbourne rates. Why the hell wouldn't booksellers do that?
Therefore the Canadians, to enforce local sourcing, had no option but to regulate pricing and availability, and guarantee booksellers and consumers comparable service standards.
Could you think of a situation less like that prevailing in Australia? The default position of Australian booksellers is exactly the opposite: to source locally. The importation route is far more costly. Trucks don't traverse the Pacific overnight. Air freighting is necessary, prohibitively expensive, and shipments are always weeks away.
What really annoys me about the booksellers' position however is this: they abandoned their consistent position over the last 20 years of supporting complete abolition of the PIRs, which would have absolutely given them what they still profess to want, and instead have opted for a nonsensical set of propositions which have ZERO chance of getting up. So they are likely to be stuck with no improvement at all.
It's been a disastrous performance and a hopelessly wrong-headed campaign. By choosing to support the publishers on the basic notion of protection, they've had nowhere to go but to invent a 'have your cake and eat it' mess, which is akin to straddling a barbed wire fence for reasons of comfort!
As for Dymocks' notion of forcing publishers to cough up 1% of their revenues to establish a fund to support the publishing of 'culturally worthy' books, the less said about this the better. It is simply one of the most absurd propositions I've ever heard advanced in all my years in the trade. Dymocks cannot claim on the one hand that publishers are massively overreacting to the prospect of an open market, and that indigenous publishing won't collapse, and then pose a 'solution' to that very prospect!
The ABA/Dymocks 'compromise' position will get no traction in Canberra whatsoever. There is only one compromise position that ticks all the necessary legal, economic and political boxes, and that's the one I myself, with great respect, have proposed (elsewhere on this blog).
My god, give me a drink..
Saturday, October 17, 2009
My Speech at Copyright Symposium, Sydney, October 16, 2009
Also on the panel were Jeremy Fisher, CEO of the Australian Society of Authors, and Margie Seale, MD of Random House Australia. They had been invited to provide a counterweight to my reformist and presumably dangerous views (hence the references to them in my speech).
I spoke first, and they responded. Frankly, it was akin to being savaged by a dead sheep!
The Parallel Importation Debate – Thank God the End is Nigh!
For the last fifteen months or so the Australian book trade has been going through the latest iteration of its favourite sport – debating whether or not to reform or abolish the parallel importation restrictions in the Copyright Act.
Like me you are all probably thoroughly sick and tired of this debate by now, and are wishing the government would hurry up and decide its position. Apparently the decision is due later this month.
In this paper I want to talk about the debate itself and how dismal the quality of it has been. I’ll be quite frank, so let me apologise up front to my industry colleagues Margie and Jeremy if I offend them.
I have been an active participant in all the flare-ups over the last twenty years, since the 30/90 day amendments were enacted into legislation in 1991. My position is well known in the industry. I am, and have always been, in favour of the abolition of the restrictions, and I think I’m the only one in the industry who has been consistent on this from day one. And I suspect that’s why my colleagues are here – to present the established industry line.
Disappointingly, what has characterised today’s debate, which, by the way, has been far fiercer, louder, angrier and more passionate than all the other ones put together, has been the centrality of the concept of territorial copyright. It has been almost universally deemed to be what the issue is all about.
In the late 80’s, in 2001 and in 2005 when we previously indulged, this was not the case. The central issue was always the theory and practice of bookseller importation, and particularly the concern that overseas remainders of original Australian titles would be brought in or dumped and flood the market.
Of the 563 submissions to the Productivity Commission this time around, all but about a dozen of them were in favour of retaining the current restrictions, and they based their view on the critical importance of territorial copyright to a healthy local publishing industry. They all assumed that the PIRs and territorial copyright were one and the same. The PIRs established the possibility of Australian authors being able to sign exclusive Australian rights with an Australian publisher, and they likewise enabled local publishers to buy exclusive Australian rights to overseas titles.
Listen to some of the submissions:
Tim Winton: ‘The erosion of ANZ rights will return Australian publishing to the colonial branch office mentality we fought against for so long.’
Peter Carey: ‘To anyone still thinking in this colonial way, there will be nothing strange about the present proposal to eliminate territorial copyright and with it the discrete Australian market’.
Richard Flanagan: ‘..many independent booksellers believe the ending of territorial copyright will lead to the further closure of independent bookstores’
The ASA: ‘The ASA strongly opposes any changes to the current provisions... that would effectively dissolve Australia as a separate rights market for books’.
The APA: ‘We believe that the real risks of abandoning territorial copyright and removing the 30/90-day rules far outweigh any potential advantages..’
There is anguish and anger here, and these emotions would be entirely justified if it were true that the reality of Australian territorial copyright were in fact under threat. But it isn’t at all.
Australia is a rights territory naturally. Just like the US and Britain it is a separate, commercially tradeable territory because of its geography, its isolation, its affluence, its established book trade infrastructure and its population size. Exclusive rights contracts can be entered into because of these factors, not because of the existence or otherwise of any importation provisions. These may give additional protection, like a fence around a house, but they don’t establish the possibility of territorial copyright, that is, owning the house, in the first place.
What has been missing from this debate is any real appreciation of how the industry actually works in regard to imported titles; any real analysis of the facts, patterns and logistics, the mechanics of the trade if you like. So much has been said that is simply nonsensical and illogical on any measure, and it’s come from a profound ignorance of industry dynamics and an adamant refusal to get familiar with them.
No one can expect the authors to be familiar with these realities, although their industry association, the ASA, has been no help to them whatsoever, and in fact has played a truly lamentable and cynical role throughout. Likewise, no one can expect outside commentators like journalists, politicians, or even lawyers, to be fully conversant with industry practices, no matter how common or basic.
But one should expect the publishers and booksellers to be across them. Unfortunately their contributions to the debate have been universally disappointing in their lack of economic literacy, lack of rigor and objectivity, and lack of any real analytical quality.
George Orwell once said that some ideas and opinions were so foolish that you had to belong to the intelligentsia to believe them. We’ve seen an exquisite instance of this phenomenon in this debate.
Industry associations are truly awful entities by definition. They invariably reflect the frightened, protectionist views of the lowest common denominator of their membership, and raise chicken little scenarios at every turn. It’s a well known syndrome and commonly understood in the halls of political power.
The APA’s contribution to the debate has been, not to put too fine a point on it, shameful. They have treated the Productivity Commission with contempt, frequently accusing it of bad faith, as if it were wilfully out to destroy culture in the pursuit of some fetid and dated ideology of economic rationalism. I defy any rational person to read the APA’s follow up submission to the Productivity Commission’s draft report and not wholeheartedly agree with me.
The Australian Booksellers Association (the ABA) has been far more respectful and measured, but its fundamental position on the issues has been wishy-washy and confused. In former times, the ABA took a real leadership role when it argued for an open market in the interests of its membership and their customers. This time round however they lost their way, concluding that the interests of independent booksellers lay with the publishers. It’s been a sublime delusion.
On the other side of the ledger I think Dymocks made a huge mistake in joining with the grocers, Coles and Woolworths, presenting themselves as the Coalition for Cheaper Books. That retail duumvirate has few friends, and can too easily be written off as an evil empire simply out to boost its profits by seeking to dominate yet another retail sector. Richard Flanagan had great sport with this at the Sydney Writers Festival, as you may remember. Dymocks, unable to get the support of the ABA, to which it belongs, should have gone it alone. It would have had much more credibility.
So, what is it about the industry dynamics that’s been missed? What are the real issues around importation?
Firstly, the great majority of overseas published titles that are brought to Australia by local publishers are NOT brought into this country under the current 30/90 day rules. They are not protected for the simple reason that they don’t need to be. To fly them in within 30 days would be artificial and silly, not to mention hideously expensive. Most parent and sister company titles of local multinationals are in this boat, as are the great majority of foreign titles marketed and distributed here under agency agreements. Titles brought in under the provisions are the cherry-picked, key sellers, and they constitute a distinct minority. There are no statistics on this, to the great frustration of the Productivity Commission and many of us in the industry.
Secondly, booksellers much prefer to order from local suppliers. They are forced to order direct from overseas, through wholesalers like Ingram and Baker and Taylor, only because local suppliers refuse to support a huge array of titles by holding stock and pricing them reasonably. Rarely would the importing bookseller get a better deal, as they have to pay freight, take a currency hedge, and are denied return rights.
Interestingly, Dymocks and Kinokuniya, the two principal booksellers arguing for an open market, have made it quite clear in their public statements and their submissions to the Productivity Commission, that they see importation as a second best option. They would much prefer to buy locally, all other things being equal.
Third, territorial copyright is a foundational concept in the global publishing industry. It’s just how things work. Authors and their agents simply get the best deal by dealing with publishers who are strong in the key territories. They’ll sell US/Canadian rights to a US publisher, Commonwealth rights to a British publisher, and occasionally, but unfortunately all too rarely, foreigners will sell Australian rights to an Australian publisher. Global rights deals are also done of course, but these are in the minority for big titles. Australian authors will sign with Australian publishers, of course. (Tim Winton’s submission to the Productivity Commission, by the way, is a superb celebration of territorial copyright and how important it is to an author).
All this simply means that exclusive rights trading primarily depends on the maturity of a territory’s book trade infrastructure and the buying publisher’s marketing and distribution strength within it. Whether that territory has parallel importation controls is an issue for the buying publisher to deal with. It is not a central, governing issue establishing the possibility of rights trading in the first place.
A number of commentators, such as Imre Saluzinsky in The Australian, have contended that it’s territorial copyright that’s the problem, and the government should accept the Productivity Commission’s recommendations and abolish it. Firstly, no change to Australia’s PIRs is going to have the slightest effect on territorial copyright – you might as well ask the government to abolish Australia’s geography – and secondly, the Commission did not recommend territorial copyright be abolished. It didn’t fall into that trap.
So putting the three things together you get the following facts of importation life: If publishers secure Australian rights, then provided they don’t screw up by over-pricing and under-servicing, booksellers will order from them. And servicing them properly, by the way, includes extending reasonable trading terms to them that fully acknowledge their overheads.
Therefore, whether booksellers would exploit the ability to buy around local publishers that a deregulated market would allow, depends entirely on the operational excellence of the local publisher. Entirely. Best practice is its own protection.
Unfortunately there are far too many examples of poor practice in this country. And this poor practice is what the publishing community is arguing should be protected by retaining the current restrictive provisions.
The Australian book buyer shouldn’t have to put up with high prices unrelated to today’s exchange rates, frequent out-of-stocks and slow delivery times. Booksellers shouldn’t have to put up with these things, as well as unresponsive customer service, inadequate title and availability information, poor sales representation, high surcharges and miserable trading terms. All of us in the industry know who these players are. Most publishers are generally good but too many are generally bad. Booksellers should, in my view, be able to buy around these uncompetitive operations, to prod them into improving their performance. Our current laws stop that from happening.
There has been a lot said and claimed about pricing during the course of this debate. All sorts of figures and stats have been thrown around, all self-serving, as you would expect. The Productivity Commission’s own analysis, however, is by far the best and most comprehensive that I’ve ever seen in all my years in the trade. That hasn’t stopped the ASA from judging it as ‘guesswork’, and the APA from condemning it as worthless. But the APA has been indulging in a massive sleight of hand on this issue, by claiming that, if you take the average A$/US$ exchange rate over the last ten years, then Australian book prices are shown to be not more expensive at all. That average is $0.69c. But it’s only that low because in the first five years the A$ plummeted to an average $0.57c, compared to $0.79c in the last five years. Today, as you know, it’s around $0.90c, and against the pound it’s the highest it’s been for 25 years. Publishers have had five or six years now to adjust to exchange realities but most have chosen not to do so. How long is the Australian consumer supposed to wait? Booksellers, on the other hand, have to compete with Amazon which uses the exchange rate operative on the very day of invoicing. Not surprisingly they are finding it hard to compete. (Publishers don’t seem to care about competition from Amazon, which I find exceedingly strange. Amazon’s market share at around $150m is now close to 10% of the Australian industry and rapidly growing).
Many supporters of the current restrictions have referred to the fact that no other country has removed its parallel importation restrictions. Once again this is a furphy. Booksellers in the UK can freely, under European law, import US editions from the open market that is continental Europe. The fact is they chose not to do so as there is little margin advantage and supply is problematic. In the US the issue is re-importation - of original US editions from low-priced developing countries - not parallel importation. In the main it simply doesn’t make sense for an American bookseller to order a British edition instead of the US edition, because the US edition is always far cheaper. There’s no commercial logic to it.
In conclusion, allow me to hazard a guess as to what the outcome of this rather unhappy debate will be. I wrote to the Prime Minister early last month suggesting a compromise, because I am not at all convinced this government has the stomach for the sort of reform that is needed. If it abolished the provisions, as it should, the squeals from the cultural community would be loud and never-ending. Yet maintaining the status quo with no real change is also not a viable political option, to so publicly humiliate its own agency, the generally well-regarded Productivity Commission.
My proposal is to maintain the 30 day protection, but only for the first five years of a title’s life, and to abolish the 90 day provision altogether. The industry could not credibly object. Dymocks and the big end of town would not be too happy but at least they would grudgingly accept that there would have been significant movement their way. Over 80% of titles in print would be available on the open market. The publishers and authors would herald the decision with a fair measure of enthusiasm and see it as a victory for their lobbying efforts. The 50,000 or so protected titles on the market at any one time would constitute the bulk of industry revenue.
I hope we don’t have too much longer to wait for the government’s decision. None of us want to read any more rubbish on this issue in the press.
Thank you.
Peter Donoughue
October, 2009
Thursday, October 8, 2009
The Real Game Changer: Amazon's Kindle Now in Australia.

Wednesday, September 30, 2009
Craig Emerson's Proposed Compromise
Here are the relevant clauses:
Berne: Article 3 (4) A work shall be considered as having been published simultaneously in several countries if it has been published in two or more countries within thirty days of its first publication.
Copyright Act: Section 29 (5) For the purposes of this Act, a publication in Australia or in any other country shall not be treated as being other than the first publication by reason only of an earlier publication elsewhere, if the two publications took place within a period of not more than thirty days.
Thus no Australian government has the authority, while ever Australia remains a signatory country, to alter the 30 days definition of simultaneous publication. And the reason for the 30 days is to allow foreign titles sufficient time to get published here in order to extend the exact same basic copyright protections to those titles that local Australian-originated titles receive. This is a foundational fairness principle in Berne, and will never change. Local titles, in any signatory country, cannot be privileged.
Try again Minister.
Wednesday, September 16, 2009
Random House and the global Dan Brown rip-off

Harry Potter is the perfect example. Dan Brown's The Lost Symbol, released yesterday, is the latest.
Random House's ARP is $49.95, an outrageous piece of price gouging if ever there was one. Similarly, the US and UK prices are at the very high end of the scale. They are all hardback editions, so the consumer is tricked into thinking that there's extra value and quality in that binding and therefore the price must be justified.
This is garbage. What's really happening is that a quintessentially mass market title is being offered in an elite package simply to screw more dollars out of the author's expectant fans.
The retailers, who know and respect their customers, are on the front line. They sacrifice their own margins to get the business and keep faith with joe public. A&R/Borders is offering it at $29.99 and Dymocks has it at $32.99. Independents Readings and The Avenue in Melbourne have it at $39.95, the best they can do because they simply don't get the sweetest terms from the publisher. Most other smaller independents can't discount at all, and have stuck to the RRP of $49.95. So if you buy from them you're being ripped off - not by them but by the publisher. What a treat for loyal customers!
I'd like to buy the book, so I'll go to Dymocks. And I'd be silly to buy from an independent, despite my usual habits and preferences.
What irks is the cynicism of Random House. A mass market product like The Lost Symbol should be produced, first up, in a paperback edition for no more than $32.95, which would then be discounted by retailers. Independents would get their usual share of demand because we're not talking big dollar price differences between stores.
Random have printed over 600,000 copies for the Australian market. I'd love to see them eat half of that because of consumer distaste.
Monday, September 7, 2009
The Australian Book Trade and Parallel Importation: a Compromise Proposal
Swan listed a few semi-forgotten things but nothing really emblematic stood out. The parallel importation issue presents a perfect opportunity for the Rudd government to firmly, clearly and very symbolically demonstrate its reform credentials; to send an unmistakable message to the big end of town, the commentariat, the ordinary voter: 'I don't just write essays about the need to improve Australia's productivity performance, the need to continue the process of reform so successfully undertaken by the Hawke and Keating governments - I'm getting on with it'.
But let's get real. Even with the cover of the Productivity Commission's report, it is extremely unlikely that this government will seize the day. First and foremost in its mind will be the loud and continuing shrieks and howls of outrage from the cultural elite if it took this course. And from the printing unions. And from state governments. And the Fairfax press. Support from the usual suspects - the Fin Review, The Australian, Bob Carr - none of this would compensate. This is a government focussed on 'palatable' policy, not policy purity.
Therefore, seeing that we're now close to the end - Cabinet's decision is expected within weeks - and we're at the final hand-to-hand combat stage, it's probably time to frame some sort of compromise position that I believe all players, however reluctantly, would accept.
I sent this letter to Kevin Rudd on September 1:
Dear Mr Rudd
The Australian Book Trade and Parallel Importation: a Compromise Proposal
The media is reporting that Cabinet may be close to debating the recommendations of the Productivity Commission to abolish the Parallel Importation Restrictions (PIRs) in the Copyright Act that currently regulate book importation into Australia by retailers.
I have been an active participant in this debate for over 20 years in my capacity as Managing Director of John Wiley and Sons Australia Ltd, a board member of the Australian Publishers Association for ten years, a past President of that association, and now, having recently retired, through my industry blog Pub Date Critical (www.peterdonoughue.blogspot.com) and my recent appointment as Adjunct Associate Professor at the University of Queensland.
I have always been in favor of reform and have been a lone voice on the publishing side of the ledger.
My sense now, however, is that the industry needs to come together around a compromise position. Such a position could be constructed by your government and I believe it would receive the support of the vast majority of authors, publishers and booksellers, and all their industry associations. It would likely also receive the support, albeit grudging, of those retailers like Dymocks who are strongly in favor of complete abolition.
My proposal would involve two elements:
1. Maintain the 30-day frontlist protection, but only for the first five years of a title's life.
2. Abolish the 90 day backlist provision altogether.
Providing local authors and publishers with protection from parallel importation for the first five years of the life of a particular title would, in virtually all cases, be more than sufficient to get a full return from the investment associated with local development, printing, marketing and selling. Very few publishing projects these days are costed with a view to a life beyond five years, although of course many continue to sell well for years beyond this period. No publisher would seriously consider not investing in a project or author on the basis that parallel importation protection would expire five years after first publication. And no author, established or otherwise, could seriously mount a case that the government had eroded his or her rights to local publication or income.
The current 90 day backlist protection is a legacy of sea freight time frames from the UK and the US and makes no sense these days when air freight is the norm. There have been calls from some industry players that the period should be shortened to 30 days or even 7 days. But allowing retailers the immediate freedom to import if the local publisher is out of stock is by far the best way to maintain competitive pressure on the privileged supplier. In the great majority of cases the retailer will wait for the publisher to re-stock because it is simply less expensive and more efficient to do so. Mostly the wait would be for only a week or two. Once the title is back in stock the local publisher would regain the protection initially afforded.
The virtue of this compromise position is that no industry party could credibly object. Those in favor of adopting the Productivity Commission's total abolition recommendations would obviously be less than happy, but they would at least be able to celebrate a significant movement their way. Close to 80% of English language titles in print would be available on the open market. The authors and publishers, on the other hand, would welcome such an outcome with a fair measure of enthusiasm. They would certainly perceive it as a victory for their lobbying efforts. The 50,000 or so protected titles on the market at any one time would constitute the bulk of industry revenue.
The other virtue of this position is that it does not involve any re-thinking of the current programs of government support for literature or publishing.
I trust you will find this proposal helpful.
Yours respectfully
Peter Donoughue
Tuesday, August 25, 2009
Melbourne Writers Festival: Panel on Parallel Importation
It was an enjoyable night, but predictably frustrating. There were about 50 people in the audience.
Here are some of the claims that were made and my responses to them. There simply wasn't time on the night to go into any depth, so I'll do that now.
1. It might be true that, technically, territorial copyright (TC) wouldn't be affected by the abolition of the parallel importation restrictions (PIRs), but the reality of it would be thoroughly subverted.
Henry Rosenbloom made this point and claimed that my separation of TC and the PIRs is a 'distinction without a difference'. Well this simply doesn't hold water. It's a neat side-stepping of the issue. For TC to be subverted booksellers would have to source a significant percentage, if not all, of their foreign-originated books from overseas wholesalers rather than from local publishers. It implies a number of things: a) that local publishers would not be able to profitably compete with overseas sources of supply; b) that, even if they could, booksellers wouldn't order from them.
Both these contentions are rubbish. Both Dymocks and Kinokuniya (the only two booksellers arguing for an open market) have repeatedly said local sources of supply are by far their preferred option, all other things being equal. It is far less expensive, far more efficient and makes inventory management far easier. But publishers must come to the party and make their offering competitive. The days of sitting back and hiding behind antiquated regulations are long gone. What is wrong with asking publishers to be competitive? Everybody benefits if they are.
2. The Productivity Commission's (PC) pricing analysis, which shows Australian prices at current exchange rates to be 30% higher than US prices of similar editions, and 50% higher than the cheapest US editions, is deeply flawed for two reasons: if the average exchange rate over the last 10 years of 0.69c is taken into account the price differential evaporates; and no account has been taken of the freight costs to ship books from the US to Australia.
As I've said before in this blog the PC's pricing analysis is one of the best things in their report. Publishers ought to do themselves and the whole debate a favor and accept it. They should also stop hiding behind the absurd ten-year average exchange rate argument. The average over the last five years is 0.79c. Today it is 0.83c. The facts here are simply incontestable. As for the freight argument this has no substance. Airfreight to Australia from the US costs about 5% - 10% of the average retail price, depending on the volume of the shipment and it's weight. Furthermore, and this is a key point, airfreight costs are part and parcel of overall trading terms negotiations with overseas principals. The higher the freight the deeper the purchasing discount, which is why Australian publishers normally get sweeter discounts from their US suppliers than their colleagues in either Canada or Britain. The same goes for shipments from the UK.
The fact that local publishers get this decided advantage from their overseas principals is precisely why retail booksellers, who will get a far worse deal on freight from the overseas wholesalers, would prefer to buy locally. Why would a bookseller pay for the freight when the publisher can much more easily absorb it, and therefore price competitively?
3. Publishers will find it hard to sell export rights to Australian titles because the buying publisher will demand a non-exclusive right to re-export their edition back to Australia, given the new open-market status of this territory.
This is an exquisite piece of illogicality! The Australian publisher obviously holds exclusive Australian rights under the contract with the author, so it's logically impossible to sign any non-exclusive deal with anyone else. As well, the only way the UK or US edition can come back to Australia is via a UK or US based wholesaler. In that case no contract is necessary.
But the root of this confusion lies in the term 'open market', which British and American publishers universally think of as a market for competing editions, all operating on a non-exclusive basis. Australia won't be like this, as I've explained in my last post. It would be more accurate to describe Australia, if the PIRs are abolished, as a 'deregulated market' where booksellers can parallel import in the hard cases.
It will be up to Australian publishers to explain these realities properly, and positively, to overseas publishers. Dopey notions need to be solidly and politely whacked.
4. Virtually the whole industry considers the PC report poison, therefore it must be!
I refuse to give this comment any credibility by spending time refuting it! We are really at the bottom of the barrel here.
5. Economic rationalism has no place in the world of books and culture. The PC report should be ignored by any government seriously interested in preserving and developing Australian writing, literature and identity. Slightly lower prices are absolutely no substitute.
Where do you start with this one? If the whiff of elitism doesn't turn you off then the cultural bunker mentality should. How dare any mere economist encroach on our pristine, privileged terrain? This stuff is straight out of the 80's. Surely we've got beyond it. By all means attack the economists' arguments, assumptions, methodologies and recommendations, but don't embarrass everybody by claiming they have no right. Ugh!